Housing Update: Fullerton Takes Steps to Address Affordability Challenges

New apartment construction tied to California housing affordability goals
Housing Update: Fullerton Takes Steps to Address Affordability Challenges

Estimated Reading Time:  6 Minutes

January 21, 2024
5:09 pm

Editor’s note: this post was updated to clarify that Fullerton is in Orange County, not the East Bay, and to reflect its housing settlement’s status in 2026 on November 14, 2026.

When we first wrote about Fullerton’s housing agreement in January 2024, we described it as an East Bay housing update. That framing was wrong. Fullerton is in Orange County, more than 350 miles south of Oakland, and new homes there will not add supply to the East Bay rental market. The story still matters to East Bay owners, though, because it showed how hard California now pushes cities on housing affordability, and the same state laws apply in Oakland, San Leandro, and every other Bay Area city.

This updated article explains what Fullerton agreed to and what happened next, how the same rules are playing out in the East Bay, and what it all means for rental property owners heading into 2027.

This article is general information, not legal advice.

What Fullerton Agreed To

New apartment construction tied to California housing affordability goals

Every California city must adopt a “housing element,” a part of its general plan showing how it will accommodate its share of regional housing needs. Fullerton missed the October 15, 2021 deadline for its 2021-2029 plan. After the city took no action for more than a year on state comments, the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) referred the matter to the Attorney General.

On January 17, 2024, the Attorney General announced a settlement with Fullerton in the form of a stipulated judgment. Under it, Fullerton agreed to:

  • adopt a compliant housing element planning for 13,209 homes, including 5,187 for low- or very low-income households
  • adopt that plan by November 5, 2024, on an expedited timeline
  • update its zoning code by December 29, 2024 to make room for those homes
  • comply with California’s Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing law
  • not deny housing projects based on zoning or general plan inconsistencies until it had a compliant plan

The settlement also set consequences for default, including possible loss of local permitting authority and monetary penalties if the city remained out of compliance.

What Has Happened Since

According to the City of Fullerton, the City Council adopted its sixth-cycle housing element on January 7, 2025, about two months after the settlement’s November 2024 target. The city also adopted a Housing Incentive Overlay Zone. The overlay allows housing on selected commercial and industrial sites, as long as 20% of the units are kept at affordable levels. It does not change the underlying zoning or require anyone to build.

The council then sent the plan to HCD for review. Approval of a plan only creates capacity for housing. Whether those homes get built depends on financing, construction costs, and developer interest.

Why Fullerton Matters for East Bay Housing Affordability

The lesson for East Bay owners is about enforcement, not supply. A decade ago, a city that missed its housing element deadline faced few practical consequences. Today the state can sue, the Attorney General can negotiate court-enforced deadlines, and cities without a compliant plan can lose the ability to deny certain projects. Every Bay Area city is working under the same law.

The Bay Area’s housing targets

The Association of Bay Area Governments (ABAG) adopted the region’s 2023-2031 allocation in December 2021. It requires Bay Area cities and counties to plan for 441,176 new homes. Oakland’s share alone is 26,251 homes between 2023 and 2031, according to the City of Oakland’s housing element dashboard. Cities report their progress to the state each April in annual progress reports.

New state tools near transit

State law has also moved beyond plans. SB 79, signed in October 2025, took effect July 1, 2026. It allows taller, denser housing on qualifying sites near major transit stops, including land within a half mile of BART stations in Alameda County. For East Bay owners near BART, this can change both the value of land and the amount of new competing rental supply over time. Our article on BART and East Bay home values covers the background.

How California Enforces Housing Element Law

Fullerton’s case followed a pattern that now plays out across the state. Understanding it helps owners read the news about their own city.

  1. The regional target. The state sets a housing need for each region, and regional bodies like ABAG divide it among cities by income level.
  2. The city’s plan. Each city drafts a housing element showing sites and programs that can accommodate its share.
  3. State review. HCD reviews the draft and either finds it in substantial compliance or sends back written findings.
  4. Enforcement. If a city misses deadlines or ignores HCD’s findings, HCD’s Housing Accountability Unit can step in and refer the case to the Attorney General. Private groups can also sue, as Californians for Homeownership did in Fullerton.
  5. Consequences. A city without a compliant plan faces limits on its ability to deny qualifying housing projects, court-ordered deadlines, and in some cases financial penalties.

For property owners, the practical result is that rezoning, ADU approvals, and housing programs are moving faster than they used to, even in cities that once resisted growth.

Housing Affordability in the East Bay Today

Plans take years to turn into buildings, and the East Bay rental market has tightened in the meantime. CBRE’s Bay Area multifamily figures for the third quarter of 2026 reported:

  • Bay Area average rent of $3,497 per unit, up 9.8% from a year earlier
  • a regional vacancy rate of 3.0%
  • year-over-year rent growth of 9.3% in Oakland/Berkeley, the strongest in the East Bay

Low vacancy and rising rents are the core of the housing affordability problem for tenants. For owners, they mean strong demand, but also more political pressure for tenant protections.

Rent limits that apply right now

Rent growth on the open market does not mean owners can raise rents freely on existing tenants:

  • Statewide: under the Tenant Protection Act (AB 1482), the maximum increase for covered units in Alameda County from August 1, 2026 through July 31, 2027 is 8.8%.
  • Oakland: the annual CPI increase for covered units is 2.3% for the same period.
  • San Leandro: a new rent stabilization ordinance starts January 1, 2027, with increases limited to the lower of 3% or 65% of CPI. See our guide to the San Leandro rent registry.

New market-rate rents mostly show up when a unit turns over, which is why vacancy planning matters as much as rent increase planning.

What Changed Since Our 2024 Article

Our original post was written days after the settlement was announced. Here is what is different now:

  • The location. We originally presented Fullerton as East Bay news. It is an Orange County city, and its new homes will not ease East Bay rents.
  • The outcome. Fullerton adopted its housing element on January 7, 2025, rather than leaving the settlement as a promise.
  • The tools. Fullerton chose an overlay zone with a 20% affordability requirement rather than rezoning sites outright, which leaves the decision to build with property owners.
  • The East Bay market. Rents in Oakland and Berkeley rose about 9.3% year over year by the third quarter of 2026, according to CBRE, and vacancy in the region stayed near 3%.
  • New state law. SB 79 now allows more housing near BART and other major transit, starting July 1, 2026.
  • Local rent rules. San Leandro adopted rent stabilization starting in 2027, and Oakland tightened rent increase and eviction rules in 2024 and 2025.

The underlying point of the original post still holds: state housing affordability policy affects how and where homes are built, and owners should follow it closely.

What Housing Affordability Policy Means for Rental Owners

Expect more regulation, not less

When cities fall behind on housing targets, the response usually includes tenant protections alongside zoning changes. In the past two years, East Bay cities have added rent registries, relocation rules, and stricter eviction requirements. Owners should budget time and money for compliance as a permanent cost of doing business.

Look for opportunities in your own property

The same push that forced Fullerton to rezone has made it easier to add units in the East Bay. State ADU laws allow many single-family and multifamily lots to add accessory units. If you have space, an ADU can add income and help with local housing affordability at the same time. Our guide to adding an ADU to an East Bay property explains how to start.

Watch your city’s housing element

Your city’s housing element lists sites that may be rezoned, programs it has committed to, and new rules it plans to adopt. Reading the action plan for your city is one of the best ways to see what is coming for rental owners.

Understand who your applicants are

High rents shape the applicant pool. More renters share units, more applicants use housing vouchers, and more households stretch to qualify. California law limits how owners can screen, including rules on source of income and how certain applicants can show they can pay. Our article on California tenant screening rules covers the details. Consistent, written screening criteria applied to every applicant are the best protection.

Plan for the long term

Housing affordability policy changes slowly but steadily. The current housing element cycle runs through 2031, and each year brings new state laws that affect rental housing. Owners who review their properties once a year, covering rents, compliance, capital needs, and local rule changes, are better placed than owners who react to each new law as it arrives.

Keep pricing grounded in data

In a tight market it is tempting to price at the top. Overpricing leads to longer vacancies, which cost more than a slightly lower rent. Use recent comparable leases, not asking rents, to set rent.

SLPM Property Management tracks local rent rules, prices units with current leasing data, and keeps owners compliant as cities respond to housing affordability pressure. To see how we would manage your East Bay rental, Get a management quote.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Fullerton in the East Bay?

No. Fullerton is in Orange County in Southern California. Its housing plan does not add supply to the East Bay market, but the state enforcement behind it applies to Bay Area cities too.

Did Fullerton adopt its housing plan?

Yes. The City of Fullerton reports that its council adopted the sixth-cycle housing element on January 7, 2025, after the state settlement required adoption by November 2024.

How many homes must the Bay Area plan for?

ABAG’s 2023-2031 allocation requires the region to plan for 441,176 new homes, including 26,251 in Oakland.

Does rising market rent mean I can raise my tenant’s rent more?

Not necessarily. Covered units are limited by AB 1482 and, in some cases, by local rent ordinances. For Oakland covered units, the current annual increase is 2.3%.

Disclaimer:
The information in this article is provided by SLPM Property Management for general informational purposes only. It is not legal, financial, tax, or investment advice, and reading it does not create a client relationship with SLPM. Landlord-tenant laws, fair housing rules, and rent and eviction regulations, including California’s Tenant Protection Act and local rent ordinances, change frequently and can vary significantly by city and county. Before making decisions about your property, lease, or tenancy, consult a qualified attorney, CPA, or other licensed professional. While we work to keep our content accurate and current as of its publication date, we make no guarantees regarding its completeness or ongoing accuracy. If you have questions about managing your rental property, contact our team.


Copyright Notice:

© 2026 SLPM Property Management. All rights reserved. No part of this article may be reproduced, reprinted, republished, or distributed in any form without prior written permission from SLPM Property Management. Brief quotations with clear attribution and a link back to the original article are permitted. For permission requests, contact us.

You might also enjoy